More than five years after publication of the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (“Proposed Rule”) in January 2021, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has published a final rule titled Changes to Support Coordinated Care and Individual Engagement and Reduce Regulatory Burdens (“Final Rule”).
The Final Rule adopts most of the January 2021 Proposed Rule’s proposals with several significant exceptions and modifications.
What You Need to Know
|
Right of Access Changes
Response Time Shortened: As proposed, covered entities must respond to access requests within 15 calendar days, down from 30. The Proposed Rule would also have shortened the permitted extension time, but the Final Rule allows one extension of up to 30 calendar days, which keeps the current extension length. The proposal to require covered entities to prioritize certain types of requests was not finalized.
Proposed New Individual Right to Inspect Not Finalized: The Proposed Rule would have created a new individual “right to inspect,” requiring covered entities to permit individuals to take notes and to take photos, videos, or use other personal resources to view and capture images of their own protected health information (PHI). This proposed new right was not adopted in the Final Rule, as HHS agreed it would be overly burdensome for covered entities to implement.
Right to Direct: The Final Rule adopts the proposal to require a covered entity to transmit an electronic copy of PHI to another person designated by the individual. Consistent with the Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health (HITECH) Act, this “right to direct” to another person is limited to PHI maintained in an electronic health record. Regarding implementation, the Final Rule provides the following:
- Covered entities must permit the right to direct where the request is “clear, conspicuous, and specific.”
- The Final Rule did not adopt the proposal requiring covered entities to allow oral requests under the right to direct. Covered entities may require these requests to be in writing, provided that individuals are notified of this requirement.
- HHS reiterated that because this is under the right of access, this right is distinct from the concept of authorization. Covered entities may not require an authorization as the written request under the right to direct.
- HHS notes that if it is unclear whether a request is an exercise of the right to direct or an individual authorization to disclose PHI, a covered entity may seek clarification; however, this does not extend the 15-day timeframe required for response.
New Definition of “Electronic Health Record”: The Final Rule adopts a new definition of “electronic health record” consistent with the statutory definition in the HITECH Act. The definition is important in understanding the scope of the right of access to direct (see above).
Proposed Requirement to Submit Requests on Behalf of an Individual Not Finalized: The Proposed Rule contemplated requiring providers and health plans (a “Requestor-Recipient”), at an individual’s direction, to submit an individual’s access request for their electronic PHI (ePHI) to another covered health care provider (the “Discloser”). This proposed new requirement was not adopted in the Final Rule, as HHS agreed it would be overly burdensome for covered entities to implement.
Form and Format of Requests for PHI: The existing right of access rule requires production of PHI in the form and format requested when “readily producible” in that form and format. The Final Rule clarifies that PHI is “readily producible” if other federal or state law requires implementation of technology that allows individuals access in that format. HHS also clarified that PHI is “readily producible” in a form and format where a covered entity makes PHI available in that form and format to other persons and where the level of risk to the security of the covered entity’s ePHI and electronic information systems is no greater than it is when providing the PHI to such other persons in that same form and format—for example, where a covered entity provides ePHI to another covered entity through a secure, standards-based application programming interface that also is capable of transmitting ePHI to a personal health app without increased security risk.
New Definition of “Personal Health Application”: The Final Rule adopts a new definition of “personal health application” consistent with the proposed definition with minor clarification. HHS stated the new definition will “support the right of an individual to obtain a copy of their PHI through a personal health app pursuant to the right of access ….” Explicitly excluded from the definition are apps where the information is managed, shared, or controlled by or primarily for a covered entity or another person.
Identity Verification: The Final Rule prohibits covered entities from imposing (a) unreasonable identity verification measures or (b) unreasonable measures that impede the submission of requests for access, including the right to direct access to another person. An unreasonable measure is one that causes an individual to expend unnecessary effort or resources when a less burdensome verification measure is practicable for the covered entity.
Fees for Access to and Copies of PHI
Fees Under the Right of Access: The Final Rule adopts, as proposed, the requirement that fees charged for responding to requests for PHI under the right of access can only include the following costs: (a) labor for copying the PHI requested by the individual in electronic or non-electronic (e.g., paper, film) form, (b) supplies for non-electronic copies, (c) actual postage and shipping for mailing non-electronic copies, and (d) preparing an explanation or summary of ePHI or non-electronic PHI, if agreed to by the individual in lieu of providing an electronic or non-electronic copy of PHI. The Final Rule also adopts the proposal to prohibit imposing any fees for in-person inspection or use of internet-based method of access provided by the covered entity.
Fees Under the Right to Direct: The Final Rule does not address fees that may be charged in response to a request under the right to direct to another person. HHS states only, “We will continue to monitor the landscape with respect to the fees charged by covered entities for copies of PHI provided in response to a request made pursuant to the right of access to direct.”
Notice of Fees: Under the Final Rule, covered entities must provide advance notice of fees for copies requested under the right of access and for disclosures under an authorization. The notice must include a fee schedule specifying standard fees that may be charged and also identify all types of access that are available free of charge. The notice must be posted on the covered entity’s website, if it has one, and available to individuals at point of service locations. The Final Rule did not finalize the proposal requiring provision of individualized estimates.
Care Coordination and Case Management
Clarification of Scope: The Final Rule amends the definition of “health care operations” to clarify that it includes individual-level care coordination and case management. HHS noted this was as always intended but deemed the clarification necessary in response to an interpretation of the definition to include only population-level care coordination and case management.
Disclosures to Social Service Agencies and Similar Third Parties: The Final Rule finalizes the proposal to expressly permit covered entities to disclose PHI, without an individual’s authorization, to social services agencies, community-based organizations, home and community-based service providers, and similar third parties for individual-level care coordination and case management activities that constitute treatment or health care operations.
Exception to Minimum Necessary Standard Not Adopted: The Proposed Rule had proposed to create a new exception to the minimum necessary standard for individual-level care coordination and case management. This proposed new exception was not adopted in the Final Rule.
Other Changes
Notice of Privacy Practices (NPP): Direct treatment providers no longer must obtain a patient’s written acknowledgment of receiving the NPP. New provisions required in the NPP are added, including (a) a description of how an individual can exercise their right of access, (b) a statement that the individual has a right to discuss the NPP with a person designated by the covered entity, and (c) modified language required in the header of the NPP.
Changes to Encourage Disclosures to Avert a Serious Threat Not Adopted: The Proposed Rule would have changed the standard for disclosures to avert a threat to health or safety. As proposed, covered entities could disclose PHI when a harm is “serious and reasonably foreseeable,” instead of the current “serious and imminent” standard. The proposal was not finalized. HHS also did not finalize the proposal to replace the “professional judgment” standard with a “good faith” standard for certain disclosures to family members, caregivers, and personal representatives.
Action Items for Covered EntitiesEven though organizations are not required to come into compliance until July 17, 2027, we strongly suggest that organizations immediately begin to evaluate the actions that need to be taken to ensure their compliance by that date. These actions include the following:
|
* * * *
For additional information about the issues discussed in this Insight, please contact the attorney(s) listed on this page or the Epstein Becker Green Health Care and Life Sciences attorney who regularly handles your legal matters.
Staff Attorney Ann W. Parks contributed to the preparation of this Insight.
People
- Member of the Firm
- Member of the Firm
- Member of the Firm